Showing posts with label Barefoot Gen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barefoot Gen. Show all posts

Wednesday, 8 November 2017

Barefoot Gen 2
Dir: Toshio Hirata, Akio Sakai
1986
****
1983’s Barefoot Gen was something of a masterpiece with no other film like it. It followed the true experiences of author Keiji Nakazawa during the end of World War II when the Americans dropped the atomic bomb on the City of Hiroshima. The conclusion of the film left the viewers with a feeling of great hope and admiration, seeing that the determination of the survivors to rebuild and continue their lives as best they could after such catastrophic devastation was the reason we enjoy many of the freedoms and opportunities we do now. It also puts a lot of modern day life in to perspective for the majority of us, indeed so much has been done to prevent such a thing ever happening again and the horrors they endured should hopefully never happen again. It was left on a positive note, however, it was just assumed that everything went well for young Gen and that was good enough an ending. To be honest I could have lived with that but thankfully Nakazawa and co saw otherwise. A huge part of Hiroshima’s devastation came after the bomb landed, and this is often overlooked and forgotten. The film takes place three years after the first film and deals with the struggles that the people of Hiroshima faced for many years. While the first movie focused on the immediate effect of the bomb, Barefoot Gen 2 focuses on the long-term problems that faced the survivors, including the devastated economy and infrastructure, food shortages, unemployment, lack of housing, and the lingering effects of the atomic bomb's radioactive fallout. For most of the film we see Gen going about his school life, getting into trouble with his adopted brother Ryuta, hanging out with a local gang and helping his mother financially the best he can using the sort of unorthodox methods war time can bring. Once again, there is a light-hearted edge to the film through the eyes of Gen, even though the serious problems of the time unwind around him. The one thing dealt with directly from the outset is Gen’s resentment of Japan being under American military occupation, everything seems to occur to him later than it does everyone else. As bright as Gen is, he still subconsciously ignores the glaring issues that surround him, including the cancer that was killing his mother. The first film looked forward to the future with determination but Barefoot Gen 2 ended with caution and uncertainty as Gen wondered how he would survive on his own. Even though the film isn’t as strong as the first, the conclusion was a brilliant move from Nakazawa, as Japan suffered uncertainty for a great many years. Nakazawa himself survived the bomb with his mother and infant sister who died several weeks afterward. While his mother didn’t die until 1966, he spend fifteen years in poverty and hardship before moving to Tokyo, finding success as a cartoonist. It was only after his mother died did he reflect on his early memories of surviving the bomb. He first wrote about fictional survivors but then in 1972 he chose to portray his own experience directly in the story Ore wa Mita. He then followed it with his Barefoot Gen series that eventually filled ten volumes. The fictional Gen was a depiction of himself but certain experiences were more harrowing in the series than they were in real life, however, nearly everything had truth to it. Nakazawa moved from his own experiences to making critical statements about the militarization of Japanese society and on the sometimes-abusive dynamics of the traditional family. Unfortunately, Nakazawa was diagnosed with lung cancer just before he was set to work on a third Barefoot Gen film that would explore the characters young adulthood, dying in December 2012. The Barefoot Gen series is a special reflection and exploration of a dark time in human history that should be remembered and never repeated, Nakazawa made this universally clear to everyone.
Barefoot Gen
Dir: Mori Masaki
1983
*****
Keiji Nakazawa’s Barefoot Gen is an adaptation of his popular Manga series that was based on his own experiences as a young boy living in Hiroshima when the atomic bomb dropped. Seen through the eyes of his ten-year-old self, the story begins and remains rather childlike, which gives the film a unique but often uncomfortable edge. Gen and his younger brother Shinji get up to mischief while their father teaches them the noble art of farming. Their mother rests as she is heavily pregnant and their elder sister studies. Apart from the odd air raid, life is normal, considering the world is at war. Nakazawa remembers his father mentioning that it is somewhat odd that Hiroshima had been left fairly unscathed since fleets of American B-29 superfortress bombers had pretty much devastated every other major City in Japan, but then thinks nothing of it. It’s a sweet anime with wide-eyed characters and full of colour. The adults are animated with realism and the children and ultra-cartoonish. Standard stuff. Then the bomb drops and the film becomes the stuff of nightmares. Imagine Totoro suddenly biting little Mei’s head off or Ponyo being stuffed, grilled and served in a seafood restaurant - times it by a million and you’re still not going to be anywhere near the horror Barefoot Gen explores. Of course, I knew that the film would feature the bombing, but I was not expecting the ferociousness and honesty to be truly depicted as it was. We see cute little children, dogs and babies melt down to their bones and characters we’d only just met and fallen for, burned alive completely uncensored. I wonder how many young children have been scared by this film, not many I hope but I do think as many kids as possible should be subjected to it. Nakazawa and director Mori Masaki were right not to shy away from the horrific reality, people melted from the fallout, so that is what they should show. Studio Ghibli’s Grave of the Fireflies came to mind while watching but the big difference is that Grave of the Fireflies keeps its sombre tone throughout, while Barefoot Gen really follows the mind-set of a child, who would treat the situation as something of an adventure or challenge. Barefoot Gen sees our protagonist try the best he can to remain a child while also trying to support what is left of his family. There is no sweetener, horror is followed by horror but weirdly Gen remains a cartoonish anime character throughout. It’s very odd but strangely moving. With any film that isn’t in the viewers language or from their culture, there will be issues in translation but I found Barefoot Gen to be the most challenging. I have no idea whether the subtitles were correct, I would guess they weren’t but the animation itself cannot lie. I found the story bizarrely playful considering the story, so much so that I can’t help but think it is Nakazawa’s true depiction. It felt a little like the anime answer to Art Spiegelman’s Maus in some respects. It’s a masterpiece of sorts for sure but I’m afraid the constant screaming of the main character really distracted from the overall story. Gen was named by Nakazawa after the terms ‘genki’ (meaning vitality of spirit) and ‘genso’ (element), as he wanted him to represent the element of the human spirit. In this respect Nakazawa certainly achieved his goal as Gen, annoying as he can sometimes be, personifies a robust determination that the people of Japan had after the war. Every country after World War II has an expression that describes its people building their lives after the atrocities they had suffered. Whether they were on the winning side or the defeated, rebuilding and continuing was paramount, some had it easier than others did, but determination and strength was key. Barefoot Gen is that spirit that saved a nation, he is Nakazawa to a point but towards the end of the film he becomes a symbol of something much bigger and more profound. It’s a very simple film in many respects, indeed, sometimes the biggest and most important messages are told in the subtlest of ways, which is certainly the case here in the film’s conclusion. It’s a phenomenal piece, totally unique and something rather special.