Annihilation
Dir: Alex Garland
2018
****
Annihilation is a lot of things. First and foremost
it is a great piece of sci-fi, but it has also kicked off a debate – two
debates in fact - that have been simmering for some time. It was always
intended that Annihilation – an adaption of the first book of Jeff VanderMeer’s
Southern Reach Trilogy – be released in cinemas. However, Paramount struck up a
deal with Netflix and the film ended up having its premiere on the
small screen. It all started after a test screening was received poorly at Paramount.
David Ellison, a financier at the studio, stated that he thought the film was
‘too intellectual’ and ‘too complicated’ and demanded changes to be made so it
would appeal to a wider audience. The big thing he wanted to change was the
ending. However, director Alex Garland and producer Scott Rudin both refused
and fought Ellison all the way. Thanks to a shift in
Paramount’s leadership and the ongoing clashes between Rudin and
Ellison, the studio decided to release it quickly and made a deal with Netflix.
Garland expressed his disappointment by saying: "We made the film for
cinema. I've got no problem with the small screen at all. The best genre piece
I've seen in a long time was The Handmaid’s Tale, so I think there's incredible
potential within that context, but if you're doing that – you make it for that
medium and you think of it in those terms. Look... it is what it is. The film
is getting a theatrical release in the States, which I'm really pleased about.
One of the big pluses of Netflix is that it goes out to a lot of people and you
don't have that strange opening weekend thing where you're wondering if anyone
is going to turn up and then if they don't, it vanishes from cinema screens in
two weeks. So it's got pluses and minuses, but from my point of view and the
collective of the people who made it – it was made to be seen on a big screen.”
I really feel for Garland because he has been wronged. I have issues with the
streaming of new films – I love the cinema experience and I don’t want to see
any more beautiful picture houses shut down and turned into Bingo Halls.
However, like Garland says, it is a great way for more people to see a film.
This is a debate that will continue for some time but if there is one thing
that Annihilation will prove, it is that studios get it very wrong and it isn’t
just ‘not quite good enough for the big screen’ films that make it to
television. Annihilation deserved a big screen outing. It has
some glorious cinematic scenes and amazing sound that justify a 90 x
30 foot screen, 2.35:1 aspect ratio and a 118dB sound system.
Paramount panicked and sold it at discount – more fool them. The
thing is, Paramount panicked for one reason and one reason only –
they think you and I are stupid. Good sci-fi is supposed to be challenging, I
get that big film studios are a business and need to make money but at the end
of the day, financial experts should not make creative decisions. It’s why so
many big chain restaurants are closing down everywhere, head office
are writing menus instead of the chiefs. Annihilation is ambiguous at times but
it is the audience’s interpretation that make it what it is. It is the sort of
film that will split audiences down the middle, indeed, the sort of film people
would have to see for themselves after hearing all the hype. Paramount probably
did themselves out of more money then they realise, but seriously, it
makes me want to avoid their films from now on, now I know they think so little
of me and my intellect (or lack of). If audiences have dumbed down, it is only
the fault of the big studios themselves, and actually, if that is the case then
I’d rather the creatives stream the good films to my home, if it means they
save money and don’t have to bother with the big studios then all the better.
The ones really missing out are the cinemas – all of which will close unless
they branch out into the home cinema market and pop corn delivery. I like the
comfort of my own home but I will be heartbroken if the cinemas go. The thing
is, I only really go to the cinema to watch big-screen-worthy pictures.
Annihilation is the most worthy big-screen picture I’ve seen for a long time.
It is criminal that it was only shown on the small screen for most people. As I
watched, I felt genuinely gutted that the amazing stuff I was seeing was
clearly smaller than was intended. The begins mysteriously and reveals itself
like a slowly peeled onion. The first part of the film felt familiar, I
wasn’t immediately drawn into it but it slowly grew on me. I did like
the subtle rationale of sending an all-female team into the shimmer, it is one
for the girls but without being forced. The turning point for me was the
discovery of what has got to be the most colourful horror scenes ever
conceived. I wasn’t convinced by monster number one but I won’t forget monster
number two in a hurry. The wonderful thing about this peculiar horror
though is that it isn’t really a horror. The audience paints the horror into
the story, the events are basically reflections of nature, which can be both
beautiful and horrific. The climax of the film is something quite profound,
again, I’m gutted I didn’t see this on the big screen. The story and imagery
may seem familiar and might have elements in common with other films (Andrei
Tarkovsky’s Stalker springing to mind) but the climax is totally original,
quite spectacular and also rather profound. It’s Natalie Portman’s best
film since Jackie and her chemistry with Oscar Isaac is both electric and
disjointed enough to keep the audience alert and intrigued. It was great
to see Tessa Thompson again and in a totally different role since she was last
seen stealing scenes in Thor: Ragnarok but the real success in the casting was
Jennifer Jason Leigh as Dr. Ventress. Garland’s direction is perfect, if you
like his other work then you won’t be disappointed. I think the cinematography
could and should have been as strong in the early segment of the film as it was
at the end and I do wish the score had been as strong as the sound effects but
other than that I thought Annihilation was bordering on 2001: A
Space Odyssey epicness. I wish it was longer, that they’d taken more
time over it and that the introduction was a little punchier. Other than
that, it’s one of the best sci-fi films I’ve seen in ages, original, compelling and
it has left me wanting more.
